Wednesday, December 10, 2008


Every few weeks I get a letter from somebody who reads this blog asking about my western novels. As mystery readers they can't imagine reading one. I never know what to say other than they're not shoot-`em-ups but rather suspense novels set in the west, some even in the Midwest. I try to make them realistic to their time. I have a large volume written in the early 1900s compiling profiles of criminals of all kinds in the United States, including the frontier. Things haven't changed much. The weapons are more deadly but the men and women using them are the same. None too bright, most of them. And they were no doubt the same in ancient Greece and down through history.

Ben Boulden just published a review of my second western and I'm publishing it here with his permission because a) who doesn't like egoboo and b) he explains far better than I can what I try to do in my westerns. His website is Gravtapping and it's a damned good one.

Leo Guild is an aging bounty hunter. He is a former lawman, father and husband, but that is all behind him. Now he rides alone. He is melancholy, intelligent and violent; when he needs to be. He also has a past that sticks with him. He killed a little girl. The courts forgave him, but he can’t find the heart to forgive himself.

Death Ground opens on the evening of Guild’s 54th birthday. In lonely celebration he makes a date at the local brothel with a young “straw-haired” girl. Things don’t go as expected with the girl and his birthday truly turns for the worse when he is summoned to the Sherriff’s office.

Two men are dead. One—Merle Rig—hired Guild as a bodyguard and the other—Kenny Tolliver—was technically Guild’s employee. He hired Kenny to protect Rig while he paid a visit to the "straw-haired" girl. As he looks at the cadavers on the heavy mortician’s tables he figures his job is gone and it is time to ride on, but first he pays a visit to Kenny’s mother. A scene that unsettles Guild and also piques his interest; Kenny’s mother knew Rig and Kenny palled around with a couple local deputies.

Leo Guild decides he can’t leave town until he figures who really killed the pair and why. He has a feeling it is not the violent mountain man being blamed by the Sherriff, but he doesn’t have many suspects. He doesn’t have anything but a hunch, really.

Death Ground isn’t a traditional Western. It, like all of Gorman’s Westerns, is a noir mystery wrapped in the trappings of the Old West. That is not to say that the historical element isn’t accurate or interesting, because it is. It is also central to the story, but an Ed Gorman Western is more of a historical mystery than anything else. A hardboiled historical mystery at that.

The prose is tough and tender in varying shades. It defines the story, action, and protagonist with a lean, smart and melancholy and literate style:

“Then he started digging snow up with both hands, and he covered them good, the two of them, and then he stood up and looked out on the unfurling white land. There was blue sky and a full yellow sun. Warmer now, there was even that kind of sweetness that comes on sunny winter days. It made him think of pretty women on ice skates, their cheeks touched perfect red by the cold, their eyes daring and blue.”

Leo Guild is an everyman. He is the man who does what needs to be done. He isn’t a hero, or a villain, but rather he is simply a man; a man who has seen much, done much, and lost much. Guild is an example of what makes Ed Gorman’s fiction so damn good: characters that are measured and three-dimensional; characters that act, feel and sound real. His male characters are strong and pitiful, lustful and scared, vain and dangerous, lonely and weak—generally all at the same time—and more importantly they are recognizable. And his female characters exhibit the same steady qualities. Neither wholly good nor bad, just human.

Death Ground is a Western that should have wide appeal. It will please the traditionalist with its rugged description of frontier life and the people who settled it. It will also introduce readers of hardboiled crime fiction to a new genre, but mostly it will please any reader who wants something tangible and meaningful mixed into a well-told, excellently plotted and immensely entertaining novel.

This one is well worth searching out.

Death Ground is the second of three novels to feature bounty man Leo Guild. It was originally published by Donald M. Evans in 1988. The other two are: Guild (1987) and Blood Game (1989). I have also read Blood Game, and it is every bit as good as Death Ground. I can only imagine that Guild holds it own as well.


Anonymous said...

This is a spot-on review Ed. The Guild books are some of your best work and Boulden has gone right to your strengths. More, please!
Terry Butler

Ben Boulden said...

Thanks for the kind words about my blog Ed. And keep writing Westerns, and hell, everything else you write. I like it all.


Judi Rohrig said...

Leo Guild is hands down one of my most favorite characters in fiction, second only to Travis McGee. Of course, it would be nice if you, Ed, could get inside Leo's head again and let him crunch through the snow, brandishing his own simple lance, jabbing at those western windmills.

Great review!


Cap'n Bob said...

There wouldn't be a smidgen of dishonesty if your western books were marketed as historical mysteries. I've read as many as I can find and enjoyed them all. People who expect shoot-'em-ups should look elsewhere. What you write are solid mystery/suspense books with strog plots and--your strong suit in my opinion--the best characters extant.